Jeffrey Pollock
Contestant # unknown
We didn't get a chance to see Jeffrey's audition, but we did see his pre-audition interview.
Jeffrey was (presumably) asked the same question that the others were asked: Why are you the next American Idol? After a moment of reflection, he says, "I think I'm the next American Idol because . . . I don't know . . . [significant pause] . . . Can I think about it?" Jeffrey gives a few more moments to think about it, with no response, before they cut away for some more auditions.
Later in the episode, they show poor Jeffrey again, still contemplating his answer. I'm sure he wasn't sitting there for that long, but I wonder how many hours he stood in line waiting to audition for American Idol — without really even knowing why he was there.